on the one hand...
|
There are two of them, a man and woman. It’s difficult to tell what age they
are, because they have obviously been drinking for many years, and possibly living on
the streets that long. It's not the first time I've seen them or their
companions, huddled in a corner muttering intently to each other. And there are one or
two young men in their twenties, a bit scruffy, hanging around, asking those who are leaving
for unwanted travelcards and those coming in whether they want one. They gaze at
the ground, their voices low, coming, it seems, not from them, but from somewhere
near them.
It's the latter half of the evening, in
Mile End underground station in east London, my local commuting point and I’m pondering
the changes that it and its immediate neighbourhood have gone through in the
last eighteen years.
When I
first moved to Bow, the area to the north of Mile End, row after row of terraced
houses and council house blocks were run down, many sites were boarded up and
derelict. But there were plans for the area. Beneficiaries of one of the
last gentrification schemes awarded by the dying Greater London Council,
my partner - purely financial - and I received a grant to rebuild the three bedroom house we had bought, in the
process installing for the first time an indoor toilet and bathroom.
The
previous owner was typical of the neighbourhood, an working-class widow while we were
typical of the middle class thirty-somethings
who were moving in as the old moved on or died. Elements of the past remained; for the first year I was woken early each
morning. first by the cock which crowed loudly a few houses away, then by the
housewife who punctiliously swept her yard a few feet from my window.
Over the next few years signs of the
upwardly mobile appeared throughout the neighbourhood. Trees were planted. Skips
hauled away rubble and fresh
paint appeared on door after door. New houses appeared on
empty sites. We became a conservation area with strict regulations about what we
could and could not do to amend our property. The local Presto supermarket
became a Safeway, offering a slightly more
sophisticated range of food and wine.
By the
mid-1990s, Bow was a tapestry of ages, classes, races and even sexualities.
Cockney could still be heard, but my neighbour and I conversed in
BBC. There was at least one African and one Indian family in the street, and an
elderly Chinese couple scurried by on their errands every day. The ethnic mix
was even greater in Roman Road
market, among both the stallholders and
buyers and in the supermarket gay men could occasionally be seen.
The changing scene was only history repeating itself. Tower Hamlets has always been a destination for
immigrants, from the seventeenth century Huguenots to the nineteenth century
Jews. In the late twentieth century it was Bangladeshis and it is they who now
form the biggest racial community. With the exception of middle-class whites
like myself each incoming group first struggled, then thrived and
integrated before moving out to wealthier boroughs. The Bangladeshis are moving
from the second to the third stage; money is being made and a third of the
councillors and the Mayor are Bengali speakers.
In the 1990s Mile End
station did not gentrify – it is used by too many students at the nearby Queen
Mary and Westfield College, and its catchment area to the south remains further
down the social ladder - but it was
refurbished. The building site opposite became an office and the nearby park was
extended and given the locally famous banana green bridge. Traffic calming schemes quietened several
roads. With cherry blossoms and brand new homes, the walk home from the tube was
no longer urban desolation, but as pleasant as a moderately busy road might be.
I began to feel myself an East Ender, at least by adoption, and to consider
myself part of the community.
But in
the last few years, the pleasure I have taken in that walk has diminished and
the community I felt I briefly belonged to has continued to change. The station is
increasingly the haunt of society’s destitute, while passers-by are from communities that a decade ago were never seen - Somalis and
Ethiopians who first arrived in the mid-1990s, other Africans who came a few
years later, now Ukrainians and Turks. And, something that used to be rare in this part of
the borough, more and more women, even the young and apparently educated,
wearing headscarves or even chadors, a display of devotion to religion as depressing as
a troupe of yarmulkes or wimples.
At the
same time, violence in the neighbourhood is increasing. In the
past month, in streets I walk through almost every day, shots have been fired at a
passing car, a student
has been stabbed to death in his flat and a teenager is killed by gunfire outside a pub.
And so the community I had begun to see as safe and familiar is neither. Of
course no racial group is to blame. The drinkers I
described at the beginning of this piece are white, while the young men
perpetrating the violence on other young men are of different
ethnicities. But, as has happened throughout history
and across the globe, when a significant number of people from one cultural
background - whether a different colour or different language or both - enters
the lives of another large group, the sense of belonging and trust in one’s
surroundings breaks down. When your neighbours look and sound very
different from yourself, you cannot help but look on them with unease - the
same unease with which they look on you. At worst there is tension and at best
discomfort and incomprehension that lasts for at least a generation.
What is
different now is the speed of change. It was centuries between the arrival
of the Huguenots and Jews, decades between the Jews and Bangladeshis, now
incomers arrive in wave after wave, from so many different places there is little time to
adjust. Furthermore, ease of contact with the homeland means there is little
incentive to integrate, so that instead of one culture there are many, sometimes
complementary, sometimes competing. The phenomenon is global and outcome
uncertain; a homogenous language and outlook by the end of the century or minor
or major conflicts across the world erupting year after year?
Ten years I was, I now
naive to think that the little world in which I lived would change
little except perhaps to become even more middle-class. I still like where I
live. My street is quiet, the neighbours friendly. I come home at all hours of
the night and do not feel afraid (the meanness of my expression and walk has
offered me protection in many parts of the world), but the ten minutes between my
house and the tube station is no longer my territory. It’s no man’s land and
will be for years to come.
|
...on the other hand
|